Emre Ergul ( Department of General Surgery, Ankara Ataturk Teaching and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey. )
Ali Erkan Ucar ( Department of General Surgery, Ankara Ataturk Teaching and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey. )
Yigit Mehmet Ozgun ( Department of General Surgery, Ankara Ataturk Teaching and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey. )
Birol Korukluoglu ( Department of General Surgery, Ankara Ataturk Teaching and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey )
Ahmet Kusdemir ( Department of General Surgery, Ankara Ataturk Teaching and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey. )
November 2008, Volume 58, Issue 11
Original Article
Abstract
Methods: Medical records of 2670 patients, who were admitted to our hospital's emergency department between January 2005 and June 2007, were reviewed. These patients were referred as acute abdominal pain by general practitioners. The data of patients were devided into sub-groups according to their age, sex, operative status, AS status and having a pathologically confirmed postoperative diagnose of acute appendicitis or not. Logistic regression analysis was performed to find out relationships among the sub-groups.
Results: Male gender (1.37), age <50 (2.4), positive family history (3.16), AS 5-6 (13) and AS ?7 (31) increased the risk of acute appendicitis. The sensitivity and specificity of AS was 91.5% and 60.5% respectively. The sensitivity and specificity of family history was 68.9% and 75.4% respectively.
Conclusion: Family history is an important parameter while predicting acute appendicitis (JPMA 58:635; 2008).
Introduction
The diagnosis of acute appendicitis is made primarily on the basis of history and physical findings, with additional assistance from laboratory and radiographic examinations. Ultrasonographic and computerized tomographic evaluations increase not only cost of treatment but also the health costs. In diagnosing appendicitis, clinicians balance the risk of misdiagnosis — removing a normal appendix in patients whose signs and symptoms may not be typical — against the risk of perforation of the appendix that might occur while waiting to see if typical findings emerge. Alvarado score (AS), is a simple scoring system that can be instituted easily.3 It is purely based on history, clinical examination, and routine laboratory tests (Table). Patients with a score of 1-4 are considered very unlikely to have appendicitis; those with a score of 5-6 are considered to have a diagnosis compatible with acute appendicitis, but not convincing enough to warrant appendectomy; those with a score of 7 or higher are considered to have probable acute appendicitis. It is shown to have a sensitivity of 72% and specificity of 81%.4
In 1937 Baker described a family pedigree in which 50% of the members were operated on for appendicitis.5 Gauderer et al. suggested that children who have appendicitis are twice more likely to have a positive family history than are those with right lower quadrant pain (but no appendicitis) and almost three times as likely to have a positive family history than are surgical controls (without abdominal pain).6 The complex segregation analysis supported a polygenic or multifactorial model with a total heritability of 56%.7 Basta et al suggested, at their case-control study, there was no evidence to support a major gene.7
The aim of this retrospective study was primarily to assess the association between family history and the occurrence of acute appendicitis. The association with age, sex, and Alvarado scoring system, was also evaluated.
Patients and Methods
The records which did not have enough information to calculate AS were excluded. In those with no information regarding family history of acute appendicitis, an attempt was made to gather the required information by phone, mail or e-mail. The patients, who could not be reached to question about the family history, were excluded.
Patients were divided into three subgroups according to their Alvarado scores. Group-A (Alvarado 1-4), Group-B (Alvarado 5-6) and Group-C (Alvarado > 7).
Any history of appendicectomy due to acute appendicitis in first-, second-, and third-degree relatives was accepted as positive family history. Appendicectomies due to other causes and no family history of appendicectomy were recorded as negative.
Data was analyzed descriptively to determine demographic characteristics of the sample. Logistic regression analysis was performed to find out relationships among age, sex, family history, Alvarado score and acute appendicitis. Data was analyzed with SPSS 11.5 package programme.
Results
The potential risks associated with age, sex, positive family history and Alvarado score on diagnosis of acute appendicitis were analyzed by using logistic regression analysis (Table 2). [(t2)]
A positive family history of acute appendicitis increased the risk of acute appendicitis by 3.158 times (95% CI: 2.519 - 3.959) in a patient with acute abdominal pain. Those patients with an AS of 5-6, and a family history of acute appendicitis were three times more likely to have appendicitis then the ones who had a negative family history.
If 7 is the cut off degree at AS, a positive predictive value of Alvarado score was 43.9% and negative predictive value was 87.5%. A sensitivity of 51.9% and specificity of 83.5% at the same condition was determined. With 5 as the cut off degree at AS, a positive predictive value of Alvarado score was 36.5% and negative predictive value was 96.6%. The sensitivity was 91.5% and specificity 60.5%.
If only family history was used as a diagnostic test, the positive predictive value and negative predictive value were 68.9% and 75.4% respectively. The sensitivity was 68.9% and specificity 75.4%.
Discussion
The increased risk of male versus female (1.37:1) and age <50 versus age > 50 (2.4:1), is quite compatible with the recent literature.2 The specificity and sensitivity of Alvarado score was reported as 72% and 81% respectively.4 Our results are not compatible with this report.
In the presented study if a patient was admitted to an emergency department with a chief complaint of acute abdominal pain, and an AS of 5-6, his risk of being acute appendicitis was 13 times greater than the one who had an AS of 1-4 with the same condition. Also, the patient with an AS of >7 has a risk of being acute appendicitis nearly 31 times grater than the one with a score of 1-4.
The advantages of ultrasonography (no radiation risk, relatively low price and 24-hour accessibility) make it the method of choice to help diagnosing acute appendicitis. However, strict criteria must be used by skilled sonologists to avoid operator-dependent differences. Also, quick accessibility of ultrasound examination must be assured to avoid delays in surgical treatment. Some studies found that in-hospital observation time was longer in perforated appendicitis.12 As the presened study had the objective of correlating the family history of appendicitis with the presenting symptoms, the ultrasound reports were not included.
Conclusion
References
2. Lally KP, Cox CS, Andrassy RJ. Appendix In: Townsend MC Jr., Beauchamp RD, Evers BM, Mattox KL, eds. Text book of surgery, 17th ed. London: WB Saunders 2004:1381-99.
3. Abdeldaim Y, Mahmood S, Mc Acinchey D. The Alvarado score as a tool for diagnosis of acute appendicitis. Ir Med J. 2007; 100:342.
4. Schneider C, Kharbanda A, Bachur R. Evaluating appendicitis scoring systems using a prospective pediatric cohort. Ann Emerg Med. 2007; 49:778-84.
5. Baker EGS. A family pedigree for appendicitis. J Hered 1937; 28:187-91.
6. Gauderer MWL, Crane MM, Green JA, Decou JM, Abrams RS. Acute appendicitis in children: The importance of family history. J Ped Surg 2001; 36:1214-17.
7. Basta M, Morton NE, Mulvihill JJ, Radovanovic Z, Radojicic C, Marinkovic D. Inheritance of acute appendicitis: Familial aggregation and evidence of polygenic transmission. Am J Hum Genet 1990; 46:377-82.
8. Andersson N, Griffiths H, Murphy J, Roll J, Serenyi A, Swann I, et al. Is appendicitis familial? Br Med J 1979; ii:697-8.
9. Basta M, Radovajicic Z, Radovajicic C. Increased frequency of Rh (E) in acute appendicitis. Hum Hered 1987; 37:384-6.
10. Basta M, Radovajicic Z, Radovajicic C. On the association between appendicitis and AB0 blood groups. Transfusion 1986; 26:305-6.
11. Rivera-Chavez FA, Peters-Hybki DL, Barber RC, Lindberg GM, Jialal I, Munford RS, et al. Innate immunity genes influence the severity of acute appendicitis. Ann Surg. 2004 Aug; 240:269-77.
12. Korner H, Sondenaa K, Soreide JA. Perforated and non-perforated acute appendicitis - one disease or two entities? Eur J Surg. 2001; 167: 525-30.
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association has agreed to receive and publish manuscripts in accordance with the principles of the following committees:




